Wednesday, October 5, 2016

Reading Uncle Tom's Cabin

For me, I agree with James Baldwin’s argument, which is “her sentimentality is nothing more than a mask for her racism, her belief that black souls and black bodies are ’fallen’ and in urgent need of salvation”. If we remove all the plots of slavery, we would find that this novel it is a normal sentimental novel that full of religion. Moreover, in my opinion, though the theme of this novel focus on slavery that is one of the most politic sensitive topics, she always try to lead strong feelings of readers and praise Christian that provide helps to black slaves.
 Like she wanted readers cry for Eva’s death in Chapter XXVI. I think even though this chapter is moving, she used too many irrelevant descriptions to create a sad atmosphere. In this chapter, we can figure out two totally different attitudes of treating black slaves by Eva and Miss Ophelia. Eva treated slaves well. When she’s dying, she still cares about all slaves in her family. Eva said that “Loving Christ most of all”. In this case, I think this beloved character, Eva, written by Stowe, is to advocate the belief of Christian. We can also find many hymns inserted in many chapters, which stands for the belief of Stowe.
   I think both two claims have their own understandings of this novel. According these two articles, I have deeper understanding of Uncle Tom’s Cabin, and realize its important significance to Civil War. Though many writers criticize that the reason why this novel so popular in America is that this novel finished in a slavery era, no one would like to write something about black slaves, we also cannot deny its influence to slavery and America. Moreover, Uncle Tom’s Cabin not only influences the development of American literature, but also influence the development of criticism literature.

2 comments:

  1. Hi Haiqin, I agreed with your opinion about Stowe gave us a strong feelings about praise Christian. I also think Tom seems like God helps him rather than a black man wants freedom and struggle against the unfair word. I think the book is too Christ. On the other hand, Stowe sharped the image of Eva is very beautiful and wrote a lots of words about her beauty. But for the black boy Henry, she only wrote a little word about him. I think there are racism.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Haiqin,

    In the section you pointed out, I too believe that there was a lot of descriptions used to describe Eva's death. However, I think it adds to the melodrama of the scene, and novel itself. Eva's death was one of the larger parts that Stowe enhances the deep care for the slaves. Baldwin would probably argue that the deep care isn't compassion, but more of needing salvation. I believe Stowe meant for scenes like this to be a call to action, despite Baldwin thinking otherwise.

    ReplyDelete